Friday, 28 September 2012

Are swimming strokes gendered?

I am a breaststroker because this is the easiest of the strokes, not because of my gender but to do with my skill level.  I know women and men swim all kinds of different ways but I think in general unconscious thinking front crawl is seen as masculine and breaststroke feminine.

A friend of mine at school once told me that swimming breaststroke encouraged bigger boobs, but I think this was wishful thinking.  Is there something in the name 'breast' which makes it feminine? The front crawl is the more dominant, faster stroke requiring more strength even at the beginners level. Does this make it more masculine?  Watching Michael Phelps swim breaststroke does ruin my hypotheses but we will rule out Olympians.

You can swim breaststroke without putting your head in the water and this therefore makes it a sociable stroke as one can chat and swim at the same time which I have seen more women do than men. Roger Deakin swam breaststroke so as not to disturb the wildlife which seems to me a wonderful reason.  He is right as to swim crawl wouldn't have enabled him to look around and enjoy the flora and fauna.  The force of the waves would have been greater and the toads would be leaping out of the way instead of admiring you.

Deakin wrote in Waterlog:

"I never worry too much about being outnumbered by crawl swimmers when I'm breaststroking up and down the lanes, but in Australia, as Ken Warpole relates in his book Staying Close to the River, it is apparently not the done thing for men to swim breaststroke, and asked why. His host, a sociologist, said, 'You should understand, Ken, that in Australia, swimming strokes are deeply gendered."

This doesn't offer us an explanation, but if the Foster's ads are anything to go by masculinity is hugely important in Australia and being weak and feminine would be the biggest insult to a man.

It is all interesting sociological thoughts, I don't think any of it affects the reality of people swimming in the UK at least, I can't speak for Australia.

I have been thinking about taking swimming lessons next spring so I can master the front crawl.  Watch this space.

1 comment:

  1. Breast stroke gives you the opportunity to see what is going on around you.
    I swim faster using breast stroke than crawl but it seems to require less effort.
    It is also a better stroke if you are in rough water.
    But, if you swim breast stroke into the wind every stroke throws up a little bow wave of water which gets flung in your face.

    ReplyDelete